Good Find. US EDITION

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Board games / A CLOSER LOOKThinkFun Cat Crimes blue English box, cardboard cat standees, rug board, round crime tokens and puzzle cards.ThinkFun · Cat Crimes · original English 40-case set

Math gamesBoard games

Who sat by both the sock and the catnip?

ThinkFun Cat Crimes

Original English 40-case deduction game

4.6 out of 55,869 ratingsBuyer feedback ↓

The flowerpot is broken. Six cats live here, but two were asleep. The rug has two socks and two sacks of catnip. Look for the one place the clues put them together.

  • 1PlayerAges 8+ · read clues alone or discuss them together
  • 40CasesTen each at Beginner, Intermediate, Advanced and Expert
  • 6SuspectsSix crime tokens and six spots around the rug
$12.59$17.99−30%

Amazon US · Original English 40-case deduction game · Affiliate link

THE QUICK TAKE

Is it right for you?

At $12.59, sold and shipped by Amazon.com, this is a good fit for a reader who enjoys taking a sentence apart. One parent watched a nine-year-old miss a case by skipping the word “not.” An English teacher reported that thirteen- and fourteen-year-olds enjoyed discussing the harder cards together. An experienced teen may prefer to try an Advanced case once the seat rules are clear.

Buy it for forty written cases. Two of eight sampled buyers specifically wanted extra cases to download or buy. Another disliked testing possible arrangements against the clues. A useful question for an older group is “Which clue proves the culprit, and which clues merely finish the map?” In the worked example below, one pair of objects settles the crime before you know where the other cats sat.

01 / BUYING NOTES

Before you buy.

01

Are blue eyes enough to name a cat?

Ginger and Tom Cat both have blue eyes. Look for a second identifying feature. Ginger has stripes, and Tom Cat wears a bow. The rulebook gives each cat two official traits, and a clue may name a trait without naming its owner.

Source ↗

Ginger and Tom Cat’s real named standees. Ginger has an orange striped coat; Tom Cat wears a blue bow.
Ginger has orange stripes. Tom Cat wears a blue bow. Both qualify for a blue-eyes clue. Image source ↗
02

Which seat has both pieces of evidence?

In the rulebook’s broken-flowerpot example, Tom Cat sat by a sock and a sack of catnip. A sock appears at two seats, and catnip appears at two. Find the seat that has <em>both</em>. It faces the flowerpot. You can now identify the culprit before placing the other cats.

Source ↗

In the flowerpot section of the rug, a striped sock lies beside a red catnip sack below the leaves.
Find the striped sock and the red catnip sack on the board beside the flowerpot. Each object turns up elsewhere on its own. Image source ↗
03

Whose left counts?

In this worked solution, Ginger sits at the fishbowl. Sassy sits directly opposite Tom Cat, so she takes the coffee spot. Duchess must sit immediately to Sassy’s own left as she faces the rug. From Sassy’s upper-left seat, that puts Duchess to the viewer’s right, at the shoes. Mr. Mittens and Pip Squeak are asleep for this case.

Source ↗

Worked flowerpot example: Sassy sits at coffee directly across from Tom Cat at the broken pot. Duchess sits at the shoes to Sassy’s own left, and Ginger sits at the fishbowl.
Worked solution to the rulebook example. With the fishbowl on the right, Tom Cat is at the lower-left flowerpot and Sassy sits directly above him. Image source ↗

ThinkFun’s Cat Crimes set ↗ · Illustrated original English rules ↗ · Publisher’s free Murdle Jr. sample ↗ · Amazon US listing ↗

02 / AMAZON REVIEWS

The buyers’ view.

AMAZON CUSTOMER RATING

4.6out of 5

5,869 global ratings

  • 5 star76%
  • 4 star16%
  • 3 star6%
  • 2 star1%
  • 1 star1%
Read customer reviews ↗

Pros

  • An eighth-grade teacher found that thirteen- and fourteen-year-olds worked together on the more difficult cases in language arts class.
  • One nine-year-old worked independently after two introductory cards. Another family kept working through new cases after school.

Cons

  • Two families wanted extra challenges after solving all forty. One specifically asked for downloadable or printed expansion cards.
  • One teacher had to remove the stands to store the cats. Another reviewer disliked trying different placements when the clues allowed two possibilities.

What buyers like

  • Gameplay375
  • Logic133
  • Difficulty109
  • Age-appropriate95

The small numbers are review mentions. Topics and sentiment are from Amazon’s customer-review overview.

Amazon US · Checked . Ratings may include other colors and sizes.

View source ↗

03 / REVIEWS & VIDEO

See it in use.

See how it works, then read the findings behind the buying advice.

ThinkFunPublisher introduction to the original game

Cat Crimes by ThinkFun

See the cats in their stands and the matching crime tokens on the rug.

Watch on YouTube ↗

ThinkFun shows the pieces in play. The family reviewers describe how the limited deck, clues with the same evidence twice and the cats’ viewpoint affect a real session.

Read 2 written sources Product scope is labeled · key findings in bold

The child needed coaching at first and stalled after a few Intermediate cards. The adult found the Expert cases challenging. They rationed the cards at the child’s level, and the double-sided cats made left-versus-right clues less intuitive.

Twin Cities Geek

Rae Black · play with a first-grader and an adult · summarized

The reviewer highlighted a useful tactic: leave a relative-position clue until one of the cats it refers to has a seat. They enjoyed solving together, noticed that evidence such as catnip appears twice, and wanted more cases once the deck ran out.

GeekDad

Stephen R. Clark · family play with a physical set · summarized

04 / COMPARE

Different priorities.

Choose the tradeoff that fits how you will use it.

Swipe to see every alternative →

ThinkFun Cat Crimes English feline deduction game · ages 8+ versus ThinkFun Dog Crimes Standalone canine deduction game · ages 8+ versus Pressman The Original Mastermind Two-player hidden-code game · ages 8+
ThinkFun Cat Crimes English feline deduction game · ages 8+THIS GUIDE

ThinkFun Cat Crimes

English feline deduction game · ages 8+
ThinkFun Dog Crimes Standalone canine deduction game · ages 8+ALTERNATIVE

ThinkFun Dog Crimes

Standalone canine deduction game · ages 8+
Pressman The Original Mastermind Two-player hidden-code game · ages 8+ALTERNATIVE

Pressman The Original Mastermind

Two-player hidden-code game · ages 8+
Amazon price
$15.19
$26.77
What counts as a clue?Use clues and dog traits to place six canine suspects on their own board.Use each row of red and white key pegs to refine the next four-color guess.
Where do new cases come from?40 new dog cases, with their own solutions and tokens.The other player makes a code each round. You can keep setting new ones.
Who solves?One solver. The complete dog game can be used on its own.Two players alternate as codemaker and codebreaker.
ExploreView on Amazon ↗Source ↗Read buying guide →Source ↗
About these everyday comparisons

Approximate comparisons to familiar objects: a bank card’s 3.37-inch long edge, a Letter sheet’s 11-inch long edge, or a US nickel’s 21.21 mm diameter / 5 g weight. Water comparisons exclude the container’s weight. Capacity comparisons describe volume, not exterior size or how food fits. Reference pictures identify the object; use the labeled ratio for the comparison.

US Mint ↗ · NIST conversions ↗

05 / PRICE HISTORY

The price over time.

ThinkFun Cat Crimes · Original English 40-case deduction game · Amazon US

Amazon and new offersOne-year view · available observations · USD
Keepa price history for ThinkFun Cat Crimes, exact ASIN B07616B2NS
Source: Keepa · Captured

The chart legend identifies Amazon and new-offer prices when available. New offers can include marketplace sellers. Coupons, shipping and size/color selections can change the final price. Blank periods are missing observations, not a zero price.